Michael Gerson: Trump is the liberal stereotype of Republicans

68
Source:   —  April 01, 2016, at 3:23 PM

Abortion is the current case in point. In the late one thousand nine hundred ninety, Trump supported the legality of partial-birth abortion. For a few hours on Wednesday, he endorsed criminal sanctions against women who have abortions.

Michael Gerson: Trump is the liberal stereotype of Republicans

This campaign season has offered an unexpected form of reality television entertainment: watching the light of discovery and calculation in Donald Trump’s eyes when he's presented with challenging policy issues, apparently for the very first time.

Abortion is the current case in point. In the late one thousand nine hundred ninety, Trump supported the legality of partial-birth abortion. For a few hours on Wednesday, he endorsed criminal sanctions against women who have abortions.

On this issue, Trump has been to the left of Harry Reid (who voted for a partial-birth abortion ban) and to the right of Mike Huckabee (who's consistently rejected punishment for women who have had abortions). And Trump is utterly incapable of defending either position. He shows number capacity for ethical reasoning – balancing claims about the ethical and valid cost of nascent life against claims about autonomy and choice.

If that seems harsh, let’s go to the transcript of MSNBC’s Chris Matthews trying to corner Trump on criminalization. Asked if this is the logical consequence of pro-life views (it isn’t), Trump doesn’t advance an argument about religion, morality and the role of law (other than to call attention to Matthews’ Catholicism). At the outset, Trump observes that “people in certain parts of the Republican Party and conservative Republicans would say, ‘Yes, they should be punished.’” Trump eventually embraces what he thinks a social conservative would say.

In fact, this isn't the pro-life position. It's the left’s stereotype of the pro-life position. “No pro-lifer would ever wish to punish a woman who's chosen abortion,” responded Jeanne Mancini, president of the March for Life. “This is against the very nature of what we're about. We invite a woman who's gone down this route to consider paths to healing, not punishment.”

Trump ended up hurting the pro-life cause by reviving a stereotype of harshness. And it's portion of a pattern.

In the immigration debate, the restrictionist side makes some serious arguments for prioritizing control of the border and for an immigration system that puts greater emphasis on skills. I generally don’t discover such arguments compelling, but they're worth debating.

Trump has not, however, made this case in any serious or systematic way. Instead, he's embraced an anti-immigrant caricature. Illegal immigrants, he says, are disproportionately “criminals” and “rapists.” The Mexican government is purposely sending criminals across the border. He retweeted that Jeb Bush “has to love the Mexican illegals because of his wife.”

When Trump eventually loses – as he certainly will in the primaries, at the conference or the common election – the movement to restrict immigration will be left as a stereotype of exclusion and bigotry.

Trump has had a similar, malignant influence on debates concerning the war against terrorism. There is number doubt that America and Europe face a heightened threat from returning Islamic State fighters, and from homegrown terrorists inspired by the Islamic State. Extra measures will be required – in the Center E and at home – to pre-empt these threats.

But Trump has chosen to inhabit a cruel and counterproductive parody of toughness. He calls for banning all Muslim immigrants. He'd conduct the war against terrorism with war crimes, such as killing the families of terrorists. He calls Syrian refugees fleeing violence the “ultimate Trojan horse.” He entertains the opportunity of using nuclear weapons against the Islamic State – which would, of course, also murder everyone the Islamic State oppresses.

This stereotype of strength actively undermines the war against terrorism by alienating Muslim allies and cultivating mistrust in Muslim communities.

For many of Trump’s supporters, this extreme and unpredictable utilize of speech is portion of the appeal. He doesn’t employ the concerned words of a politician. He's so appealingly unprepared. So refreshingly ignorant. So disarmingly half-baked.

But the durability of Trump’s appeal creates a conundrum for many Republicans. For decades, some of us have argued that the liberal stereotype of Republicans as extreme, dim and intolerant is inaccurate and unfair. But here is a candidate for president who fully embodies the liberal stereotype of Republicans – who thinks this is the way a conservative should sound – and has found support from a committed plurality of the party.

If the worst enemies of conservatism were to construct a Frankenstein figure that represents the worst elements of right-wing politics, Donald Trump would be it. But it's Republicans who are giving him life. And the damage is already deep.

READ ALSO
Diablo Canyon is needed for clean-energy transition

Diablo Canyon is needed for clean-energy transition

The State Lands Commission is scheduled to consider extensions for leases set to expire in two thousand-eighteenth and two thousand nineteen at the Diablo Canyon nuclear power plant.

51
Anti-vax measles outbreak forces quarantine in NV County

Anti-vax measles outbreak forces quarantine in NV County

The reason? An unvaccinated baby who . Yes, California, it happened again. Faced with the contagious nature of the childhood sickness (see “”) and the fact that's a Waldorf school with a vaccination rate far, distant below the mid-90-percent range needed...

68
Time for CA companies to speak up on Trump

Time for CA companies to speak up on Trump

Activists are urging at minimum three CA companies – Google, Adobe and Cisco – to withdraw funding and in-kind product donations that they'd pledged to the convention’s Host Committee.

66
F1 qualifying changes 'a mistake,' says U. S. racing legend Mario Andretti

F1 qualifying changes 'a mistake,' says U. S. racing legend Mario Andretti

American motor racing legend Mario Andretti is the latest title to speak out against this season'south controversial regulation changes in Formula One.

65